I know, I know… when human resources people pushed back, it probably meant they were saving me from myself. And, to be fair, I know that there are lots of exceptional, appreciated human resources professionals out there who are making significant impacts on the cultures and bottom lines of their organizations. Unfortunately for me, I’ve only had the pleasure of crossing paths with one of them in my entire career (and he was a client so I pretty much had to like him).

HR-speak is akin to PR spin. It’s filled with empty catchphrases, trendy buzzwords, and legal counsel-approved language that mollifies executive leadership and mortifies the rank-and-file who see right through it. I’m still aghast at the response an internal Human resources executive once gave me when I complained about the unimpressive job candidates she was sending me: “You know, Eric, your standards are just a little too high.”

Needless to say, I perked up when I read that Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer shares my critical view of HR folks. According to a fascinating article in the current issue of BusinessWeek by Michelle Conlin and Jay Greene, Microsoft was suffering a serious brain drain two years ago. But instead of hiring a traditional HR executive to turn things around, Ballmer gave the HR reins to Lisa Brummel, a popular and experienced product manager that he moved over from the Home & Retail Division. Ms. Brummel has achieved considerable success in the two years she’s held the top spot, no doubt because she refused to follow “the usual HR script.”

Some examples:

• Brummel refused to benchmark “best practices” at other companies, much less impose them on Microsoft employees. “Before you go running off campus, you should know what’s going on on campus.”
• She quickly established a reputation as a “no-B.S., jargon-allergic, truth-teller” when she admitted to reading a popular and highly critical Microsoft blog written by an anonymous employee.
• She eliminated the bell curve in annual employee performance evaluations.

The BusinessWeek article is a great read for anyone desperate to have their faith restored in the potential of the human resources function. On the flip side, anonymous Microsoft employee blogger “Mini-Microsoft” suggests that BusinessWeek is a tad too generous in its praise of Brummel and her efforts. [Tough crowd – HR really is a thankless function!]

Still, Conlin and Greene deserve kudos for reporting on the untraditional approach and its impact to date. The bottom line is that Brummel seems to be staunching the company’s employee hemorrhage… at least for now (all bets are off if she takes the towels away again).

Now if only Brummel could do something about Microsoft’s ghastly “Your potential. Our passion.” tagline.

Share This Post